A very interesting topic. We need more of such, I reckon.

Unsurprisingly, some interesting characters also popped up here. Yes, we want a diversity of opinions and ideas. However, I think some of these doubters seemed to believe everyone, including the scientists, are wrong, and they, albeit a handful of them here, are right

So these geniuses theorized that water is not essential for life forms to exist. Fair enough thought if they can proving instances where it is valid. But hello...There is none but some clever, half-ass assertions which amount to nothing.

For their information, life forms are composed of organic matters. For organic matters to mix and react, to procreate, there must be water. Have you tried making a cup of tea with just air ? Water is a medium to accommodate the conference of chemicals compounds, just like the water you used when you dumped tea leaves into the boiling water.

Yes, it just may be possible that life forms may exist without water. However, to date, there is no such evidence to support such claims.

Select to expand quote

Jupiter said..

For their information, life forms are composed of organic matters. For organic matters to mix and react, to procreate, there must be water. Have you tried making a cup of tea with just air ?

So if no water to procreate, when we hit the money shot it would be like a puff of powder.

Dexter had it sussed out in 1976 - extreme funk alert!

And they are not supposed to send Rover to check out the water....

www.sciencealert.com/here-s-why-nasa-s-mars-rovers-are-banned-from-investigating-that-liquid-water

Select to expand quote

dmitri said..
"The bounties of space, of infinite outwardness, were three: empty heroics, low comedy, and pointless death"

Kurt Vonnegut, The Sirens of Titan

One of the best quotes I've ever seen on the breeze dmitri...