Been lucky to get some fun sessions on the new 2018 S1 pros, and tried the 5.2, 4.8, 4.4, 4.0. Got a set of 3.6/4.0/4.4/4.8/5.2. I share these with my girlfriend, I'm 68kg and she's maybe 58kg (this could get me in trouble!). It works really well for us with the sail sizes, and we both feel pretty much the same way about the sails, having used them the last few years.
We did not have the 2017 sails, so can only compare to the 2016.
Firstly, the sails look awesome! Love that new gear motivation too, and that first bottom turn looking through the super clear window

The sails are physically light, and on the water they also feel super light, balanced and ridiculously efficient. Put in a tack (often my best move) and the sail just stands up on it's own - you can let go during the transition round the mast and it just effortlessly stays there.
Sailing along the sail is exciting to use, it feels alive. There is always pressure in the back hand, but you don't have to hang onto it or fight against it - the power is there when you need it.
On the wave the sail is super easy to control throughout the turn. So easy to control into the bottom turn with the sail going really light in the hands, but then as you look up the face and start to open up, the leach reacts instantly to allow you to drive at the lip, but still giving easy control.
The main differences I can see and feel compared to the 2016 model are:
The clew is lower (I think the boom cutout on the luff for the boom reaches lower too).
They have a huge tuning range this year. If I set the sail as I would my 2016 model (loose leach across 1/3 of top panel maximum), it would have more bottom end power/grunt. Interestingly, the 2018 sails also seem to like more downhaul and outhaul tension too, giving them better top end! Therefore with the new sails, you can get away with hanging onto one sail longer and tune for the changes in the conditions more than before

Physically picking up the sails they feel a little heavier (still way lighter than anything else on the market, the 5.6 weighing in at 2.7kg, lighter than most 3.6 sails....), and when rolling the sail it feels thicker. This is a positive point as it means the sails must be stronger with more of the special Hyperspider fibres and maybe an increase in film thickness?
These sails are not going to help me to "bulk up", but I am sure the efficiency and light weight allows me to stay on the water for longer