Back to top

Shark

Created by slalomfreak slalomfreak  > 9 months ago, 10 Feb 2017
Register to post, see what you've read, and subscribe to topics.
slalomfreak
slalomfreak

NSW

304 posts

10 Feb 2017 11:15pm
www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4210682/Kite-surfer-s-encounter-bull-shark-Brighton-Le-Sands.html
This must have been the one Rick thought he saw on Thursday arvo!
stehsegler
stehsegler

WA

3557 posts

12 Feb 2017 1:26pm
From the article: "Beware swimming at the moment, they are even taking hooked up fish from anglers of late," Anthony Grech commented on the video.

I think if you are thinking about going for a swim in the canals down that way perhaps sharks are the least of your problems.
benyip
benyip

NSW

76 posts

12 Feb 2017 8:38pm
I won't windsurf for the moment, especially every water start is a scary moment
gavnwend
gavnwend

WA

1373 posts

12 Feb 2017 5:49pm
I saw three or four of them today out at kurnell (juveniles).never seen one in my 17 years sailing the bay until today.they must be chasing fish who knows.
Waiting4wind
Waiting4wind

NSW

1871 posts

12 Feb 2017 10:00pm
I'm glad I didn't read this before thrashing around in the water today. Gybe count was low in the 30+ knot southerly and 1m+ swell.
Mishka
Mishka

NSW

19 posts

13 Feb 2017 10:21am
As long as Botany Bay is not a patrolled beach, I am wondering if any shark tracking activities are taking place in the area, or they only rely on eyewitnesses? How do we know when it is safe to sail there again?
Ian K
Ian K

WA

4164 posts

13 Feb 2017 9:15am
Select to expand quote
Mishka said..
As long as Botany Bay is not a patrolled beach, I am wondering if any shark tracking activities are taking place in the area, or they only rely on eyewitnesses? How do we know when it is safe to sail there again?


There's probably 100 sharks in Botany Bay right now, the fact that one has just been spotted doesn't make it more or less safe.

Patrolled beaches? I spotted a shark(s) 500 metres from a patrolled beach the other day, not a big one, about the weight of a pit-bull or two, it had teeth. Thought I'd better report it to the Life Saver, he had about 50 swimmers between the flags. "How far out?" he asked. "Let me know if it comes closer". When I came in again he did wander down to ask me if I could still see it out there.


stehsegler
stehsegler

WA

3557 posts

13 Feb 2017 9:57am
Select to expand quote
gavnwend said..
I saw three or four of them today out at kurnell (juveniles).never seen one in my 17 years sailing the bay until today.they must be chasing fish who knows.


I guess you never sailed out at La Perouse. Seen plenty around that area. Deep water channel with a good tidal flow attracts a lot of fish... small and big. This article from a few years ago comes to mind:www.smh.com.au/national/patrols-seek-sydneys-monster-shark-20070208-gdpf8a.html
Waiting4wind
Waiting4wind

NSW

1871 posts

13 Feb 2017 5:47pm
Select to expand quote
Mishka said..
As long as Botany Bay is not a patrolled beach, I am wondering if any shark tracking activities are taking place in the area, or they only rely on eyewitnesses? How do we know when it is safe to sail there again?


It will be safe on this wed, thurs and Friday as there is an epic NEr forecast.

thenonly bites I got on Sunday we're from jelly fish, so all good
MrBlean
MrBlean

NSW

11 posts

15 Feb 2017 11:28am
A typical piece of hyped up reporting. First: "The unbelievable footage shows the unaware kite surfer coming within centimetres of the shark as he heads back to dry land."

Indeed, about 1000 cm I would estimate, or 10 metres if you want to use a more realistic gauge of the distance involved. But, "within centimetres" makes it sound within biting range so all the more scary, eh?

"Terrifying footage" terrifying for whom? The reader or the kitesurfer who, in the previous sentence quoted above, was claimed to be "unaware"? Difficult to be terrified when you don't even know what's going on!

And the kitesurfer was "head(ing) back to dry land". What's wrong with the term "beach"? Of course, "dry land" sounds further away from the shark and hence safer as, other than in the movie 'Jaws', sharks aren't known for leaping out of the water in pursuit of human prey.

The best bit is the statement from camera man Adam Cartmer: "You could see it wasn't going to attack - I was near it in knee deep water. It was a little disoriented".

Moreover, "The sighting comes after a strikingly similar shark was spotted in shallow waters at nearby La Perouse on Monday". Similar in that it had fins, a tail and was in the ocean, I'm guessing?

As Ian K said, there are probably 100 (if you count the small ones, thousands of) sharks in Botany Bay right now. But it's difficult to spot 'em if nobody is within eyeshot. The only ones that get seen are the ones where there are people present, usually lots of people, as this increases the odds of the shark(s) being seen. Perhaps that would explain the claim that: "sharks are drawn to unmeshed swimming spots in the warmer months." Wouldn't it have been better to have said swimmers are urged to stay inside meshed swimming areas as sharks are drawn into shallow water in the warmer months (if that is even true), rather than suggest sharks deliberately target swimming areas?

The world's oceans are full of sharks of lots of different types. If you spend time in it or on it, sooner or later you will have a close encounter with one.

And finally, when viewed from above, how come there are so many people who are able to recognise the precise species of shark in question? This one is supposedly a bull shark but I guess that makes a change from the ubiquitous great white. Jaws has a lot to answer for - as Peter Benchley, the author of the original book on which the move is based - to his deep regret, became painfully aware.

This type of reporting perpetuates the myth that Peter Benchley spent the balance of his life trying to dispel. But it sells newspapers, doesn't it?

www.livescience.com/8309-jaws-changed-view-great-white-sharks.html

narrative.ly/how-the-creator-of-jaws-became-the-sharks-greatest-defender

www.boston.com/culture/entertainment/2015/06/19/why-the-author-of-jaws-wished-he-never-wrote-it
Harrow
Harrow

NSW

4521 posts

15 Feb 2017 9:23pm
Should help ease the parking congestion at the end of Bestic Street. More coverage in the mainstream media, please!
gavnwend
gavnwend

WA

1373 posts

16 Feb 2017 9:29am
The last fatalitie in botany bay was nearly 80 years ago (1940).brighton le sands.having said that are we due! Hope not.
gavnwend
gavnwend

WA

1373 posts

28 Feb 2017 3:59pm
Rip. Little fur baby.the dog taken at kurnell on sunday.
End of posts
Please Register, or first...
Topics Subscribe Reply

Return To Classic site