Select to expand quote
terminal said..
There is plenty of cheap windsurf gear that would make good learning setups, but the manufacturers have no interest in that route
It's way too easy to blame the manufacturers. BIC makes excellent sailable SUPs that are great for teaching windsurfing, and quite affordable (about $1200 US). But most windsurfers I know would never buy a BIC.
I think feedback from bystanders on the beach is useful. I often sail at a beach with lots of tourists where there are typically more windsurfers than kiters. Tourists always ask about kiting - it looks cool, and kiters get air even in relatively light winds. The
only time tourists ever ask about windsurfing is when they see someone doing cool freestyle, including light wind freestyle. Of the few younger windsurfers I know, most go towards freestyle, too. With the new freestyle gear, they get crazy good in a couple of years. But there are not many of them.
I think going back and forth for hours is lots of fun, and putting on a GPS makes it even more fun. Most windsurfers I know agree and do the same thing. But while this is fun, it
looks boring. Why learn a boring sport?
The argument that wide boards have made it easier to learn windsurfing and thereby helped windsurfing is often repeated, but I don't buy it. Yes, you can learn to go back and forth on a windsurfer in a couple of hours in light wind. But you're in for a rude awakening when the wind picks up - you see that you really don't know anything. When I learned in 1979, it took 3 days before we reached the point of being able to sail, turn, and get back to where we started. That certainly gave you a feeling for accomplishment, and an understanding that windsurfing is
not easy. I just watched a bunch of beginners learn kiting in Tobago. Surprise - it also takes them three days before they even have a change to go back and forth, and end up where they started, with a lot of frustration for many when they try to get up onto the board the first time (or rather, the first 20 times). The kitesurfing school there told everyone it takes a few days to learn to kite, but they still had a lot of business.
Perhaps teaching windsurfing is harder. The store in Tobago did not even have anyone to teach beginners windsurfing; I saw them turn people way. In the US, there is just one level of windsurf instructors. Instructor lessons are limited to the very basics. There is no program at all in the US to teach how to teach intermediate or advanced lessons (including beach starts, water starts, and planing). There
are a few good professional teachers in the US, many of them who spend years with ABK Boardsports to learn how to teach. With proper instruction over a 5-day class, I have seen absolute beginners proceed to beach starts, getting into the front straps, and water starts.
If you want to blame the industry, I'd say blame Starboard. With their monster-wide boards, they created the illusion that it's so easy to learn windsurfing that you can learn it in an hour. Except that this is on a door that is absolutely no fun to sail in light winds, very different from older gear that actually was (and still is) fun in light winds. It's almost "false advertising".
But I don't think blaming Starboard is the answer, or even makes sense. Some of their ideas where partly copied by others and helped (for example, 85 cm wide beginner boards, instead of 70 cm or 100 cm wide boards). A more relevant question is: why would anyone want to start windsurfing? In the 80s, windsurfing was new, which was reason enough. Many new windsurfers came from surfing, and the windsurf board was huge in comparison. Now, the "new and cool" still applies to kiting, but not to windsurfing. If you want more people to get interested in windsurfing, show them cool stuff instead of lawn mowing - learn ankle biters, rail rides, loops, or new school tricks, and show them near the beach!