Please note: We are temporarily in maintenance mode, and some features, such as Buy&Sell, Forums and Messaging are temporarily offline. Back soon!

Forums > Windsurfing General

Best no cam free ride sail

Reply
Created by Mistral Nick > 9 months ago, 2 Jul 2012
Mistral Nick
QLD, 370 posts
2 Jul 2012 7:29PM
Thumbs Up

My old Gun 7.5 is about to die and I would like some opinions as to what is considered the best no cam free ride sail of a similar size . I'm considering Loft O2 7.4. North X type 7.3, Hellcat 7.2.Simmer , Naish Rally
I'm of the opinion their performance characteristics for my level are fairly close to cammed sails but what to choose , something with low down grunt and good top end.

kiteboy dave
QLD, 6525 posts
2 Jul 2012 7:44PM
Thumbs Up

Mate I reckon an Ozone Catalyst 12m should do the trick, really nice freeride sail, no cams in sight.

Mistral Nick
QLD, 370 posts
2 Jul 2012 8:27PM
Thumbs Up

Onya kiteboy, love constructive suggestions. Maybe worth a shot a sneaky peak at the dark side.

Mistral Nick
QLD, 370 posts
2 Jul 2012 8:29PM
Thumbs Up

Hmmm just realised , bit of brain fade into the wrong forum, apologies all.

GreenPat
QLD, 4096 posts
2 Jul 2012 8:43PM
Thumbs Up

^^ Fixed.

Mobydisc
NSW, 9029 posts
2 Jul 2012 8:48PM
Thumbs Up

Have a read of my review of the HSM Speed Demon in the review forum. They are available at a very reasonable price including the recommended mast. I like them.

I had Loft 02s, actually I still have one and I like them too. However I never had the right mast for them.



SHQ
VIC, 322 posts
Site Sponsor
2 Jul 2012 9:30PM
Thumbs Up

The NP Hellcat 7.2 in our opinion is the best no cam sail out there, great low down grunt and unmatched top end speed and control.

Victor B
WA, 130 posts
2 Jul 2012 7:46PM
Thumbs Up

IMO as a moderate skilled sailor - Tushingham T4's are worth a look...

and even consider the Tushingham 2 cam Lightning if you want something halfway between performance cam and no cams.

Severne NCX also a good no cam freeride sail.

Ellobuddha
NSW, 625 posts
2 Jul 2012 11:46PM
Thumbs Up

+1 for Loft O2. Great sail at great price. Got three of them.

Darkplague
SA, 197 posts
2 Jul 2012 11:37PM
Thumbs Up

+2 for Loft O2

Bought an O2 2009 7.4m sail (in average cond) for about $50 2 years ago.
Been waiting for it to die so I can upgrade to new model, however it just keeps going and going, so I just keep using it :P

SailCoothara
VIC, 137 posts
3 Jul 2012 1:34AM
Thumbs Up

Gaastra Matrix!! Can't find them anymore though :(

FiremanSam
VIC, 148 posts
3 Jul 2012 8:26AM
Thumbs Up

Love my KA Koyote 7.4 !!

lao shi
WA, 1343 posts
3 Jul 2012 8:02AM
Thumbs Up

Sailed the 2011 X-type 7.3? back to back with the 2012 KA Kyote 7.4 and the KA had much more grunt and held its shape during the lulls. Both rigged on 460 powerex skinny.

Waiting4wind
NSW, 1871 posts
3 Jul 2012 10:34AM
Thumbs Up

If you already have a mast them this will limit your options. You need to work out what sails are going to be compatible to your mast.

You could also probably go a step bigger (7.7-8) as a current model sails should have a better range than the old gun.

Reflex Films
WA, 1459 posts
3 Jul 2012 9:56AM
Thumbs Up

Without bringing in my personal opinion - which is admittedly very biased- i will confer to facts and third parties:


there are a heap of reviews on this page from magazines:

http://www.severnesails.com/2012/media/test_result.php

www.severnesails.com/blog/who-wants-to-go-fast-with-no-cams

The NCX is consistently reviewed as the fastest and best handling No cam freeride in magazine tests - and uses a good chunk of the DNA that is making the Reflex race sail program the fastest and most sought after race sail on the market.

Usually at a price tag that is within $50 of most other offerings in the market. But probably more expensive than internet direct offerings. Its certainly great value for money - but not a cheap offering.

As with any sail -You will need the correct mast curves to get the best performance.

If you are looking for more durability / low end grunt - then the all X ply Gator is the option to look at.

I was on a wavesailing mission in Vietnam a few years ago - and had some good fun wavesailing - but one of the most memorable sessions i had was on a 7.5 freeride sail and a 110 litre fast freeride board. Jus tmagic - it felt like i was sailing "downhill" the whole time

There are quite a few demo NCXs 7.5s / correct masts floating around at shops - especially in Brisbane and on the Sunshine coast -so you can actually ride one before you commit to anything.

- No cam freerides are awesome sails to enjoy pure blasting on.

Do your research , find your desired price / performance point and make an informed decision. Hope that helps and good luck whichever way you go.

jsnfok
WA, 899 posts
3 Jul 2012 10:13AM
Thumbs Up

Mistral Nick said...

My old Gun 7.5 is about to die and I would like some opinions as to what is considered the best no cam free ride sail of a similar size . I'm considering Loft O2 7.4. North X type 7.3, Hellcat 7.2.Simmer , Naish Rally
I'm of the opinion their performance characteristics for my level are fairly close to cammed sails but what to choose , something with low down grunt and good top end.



severne ncx, dont bother with the X-Type unless you are using a big board

firiebob
WA, 3177 posts
3 Jul 2012 1:37PM
Thumbs Up

Disclaimer, I've only ever used or owned 1 no cam. I have a 5.9 Loft O2 and love it, I use it on a slalom board and usually only when it's windy and the water is rough, sweet sail. I do use it on Green Island when windy and have scored 37 knots on the old gps dial. I have been using an old Ezzy skinny mast with the head adjusted to suit the extra length with no drama but they also work with standard diameter masts.

Here's a short video I've posted before...

evlPanda
NSW, 9207 posts
3 Jul 2012 4:38PM
Thumbs Up

What mast do you have?

(there's an old Koyote 7.2 in surfFx you might like)

K Dog
VIC, 1847 posts
3 Jul 2012 5:43PM
Thumbs Up

(Flame suit) What's wrong with Cams?

I love the feel of cams in a sail - holds a great shape, good power, feels really solid.....

I know this is a non cam thread, but curious why the preference? I can understand no cams on small sails, but when you are in the 7m range... I recon cams all the way....

Rob11
240 posts
3 Jul 2012 4:35PM
Thumbs Up

That's another brand bashing thread where everyone is gonna push for the brand they use (and probably can't compare to anything as they haven't used anything else... same for the shops that sell one or two brands only).

I guess the only constructive comment is from Waiting4wind, the mast will dictacte which way to go unless you consider replacing the lot.

sboardcrazy
NSW, 8292 posts
3 Jul 2012 8:29PM
Thumbs Up

K Dog said...

(Flame suit) What's wrong with Cams?

I love the feel of cams in a sail - holds a great shape, good power, feels really solid.....

I know this is a non cam thread, but curious why the preference? I can understand no cams on small sails, but when you are in the 7m range... I recon cams all the way....

Even though I'm probably about to buy a cammed sail ( mainly because its in my budget - can't afford a non cammed setup) as a smaller female sailor ( weaker, shorter lighter) I find cammed sails are harder to waterstart & uphaul especially if they get the luff tube full of water. Also when I muff a gybe and the sail is popped the wrong way when I go to start I find it very draining to have to push the sail up & jerk it to get the sail to rotate so its set up for easy waterstarting.
If I could guarantee never to fall in again I love them! Stable and controllable.

Mike105
59 posts
3 Jul 2012 6:39PM
Thumbs Up

Have just been through the same process researching all the options including cam versus no-cam. Came to the no-cam conclusion, but could easily have gone the other way.

As Waiting for Wind says, comes down to the mast. Mast compatibility is a mine field and if you've already forked out $$$ on a good mast don't compromise performance with a sail that doesn't match. See the mast bend curves thread, and watch out for some of the major brands who seem to have changed bend curves over the last few years making the second hand market even more complicated.

Have a Speed Demon as I was already on Hot Sails. Haven't got it wet yet. It's brass monkeys weather in NZ at the Mo.

Mobydisc
NSW, 9029 posts
3 Jul 2012 9:26PM
Thumbs Up

K Dog said...

(Flame suit) What's wrong with Cams?

I love the feel of cams in a sail - holds a great shape, good power, feels really solid.....

I know this is a non cam thread, but curious why the preference? I can understand no cams on small sails, but when you are in the 7m range... I recon cams all the way....




I've gone from cammed sails for a few reasons.

Firstly I disliked the complex rigging process of cammed sails.

Secondly I did not like their weight and what have become huge luff pockets on modern cammed sails.

Thirdly I found them difficult to waterstart and uphaul.

Fourthly they are more reasonably priced.

Finally I've found modern non cammed sails such as the Loft 02 and the Hot Sails Maui Speed Demon to be excellent sails. As Reflex Films describes, sailing one that is correctly rigged on the right mast is a real joy to sail with a light, smooth and slippery feeling through the wind. I fully understand that downhill sailing feeling when going for it off the wind.

There was no performance advantage for me with a cammed sail so I've sold them all.

Besides this thread being full of opinions it also shows we live in a great age of competition between the brands that results in us being able to purchase great sails at very reasonable prices.

Mobydisc
NSW, 9029 posts
4 Jul 2012 8:17AM
Thumbs Up

Mobydisc said...
Fourthly they are more reasonably priced.





My bad with the above point, I meant cam free sails are more reasonably priced. They can be bought from under $600 new which is a fair saving on the cost of cammed sail.

Waiting4wind
NSW, 1871 posts
4 Jul 2012 2:44PM
Thumbs Up

Mike105 said...

. Mast compatibility is a mine field and if you've already forked out $$$ on a good mast don't compromise performance with a sail that doesn't match. See the mast bend curves thread, and watch out for some of the major brands who seem to have changed bend curves over the last few years making the second hand market even more complicated.



I can vouch for this having recently tried a new sail brand on a different manufacturers mast which was supposed to be compatible. I even demoed a small size on my existing mast. However the new sail in the larger size, while it worked on the old mast it didn't feel 100%.

I then bit the bullet and bought a new mast, the difference in feel and performance was chalk and cheese.

I've had a range of N Pryde sails and the Hellcat wasn't my favourite in the earlier series ( I prefered the Saber model before it). If you tuned the sail for top end it felt a bit gutless and when bagged out for light wind it quickly became back handed - hence I refrered to it as the Hellpussy.

However I did have an opportunity to play with a 2012 model Hellcat, but no real wind to test properly. What i did notice is that even when DH to max reccommended it still had heaps of curve / belly under the boom, while the top was twisting nicely. So if you're looking at Hellcat I'd go for the 2012, very nice!.

But definitely try your mast on the prospect sail before buying or use the reccommended mast.

Most of the current brands are very good sails but can feel very different on the water, so it also comes down a little to what sort of feel you're used to.

Mistral Nick
QLD, 370 posts
4 Jul 2012 6:11PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks for all your opinions. I have nearly always had cammed sails over my 30years of sailing, however I am thinking of simplicity and my old Gun Booster 7.5 weighs a ton or feels like it, although it worked quite well as a light wind sail matched with my Mistral Screamer 115.
After reading a few tests it occurred to me that for my ability and level of performance I need not fork out for a full on race sail and I have usually been competitive with my sailing mates without spending heaps. I still have a KA Concept 6.6.
My mast is Loft 80% 460 sdm which I believe is a constant curve.

WINDSURFnSNOW
NSW, 1613 posts
Site Sponsor
4 Jul 2012 8:42PM
Thumbs Up

Waiting4wind said...

Mike105 said...

. Mast compatibility is a mine field and if you've already forked out $$$ on a good mast don't compromise performance with a sail that doesn't match. See the mast bend curves thread, and watch out for some of the major brands who seem to have changed bend curves over the last few years making the second hand market even more complicated.



I can vouch for this having recently tried a new sail brand on a different manufacturers mast which was supposed to be compatible. I even demoed a small size on my existing mast. However the new sail in the larger size, while it worked on the old mast it didn't feel 100%.

I then bit the bullet and bought a new mast, the difference in feel and performance was chalk and cheese.

I've had a range of N Pryde sails and the Hellcat wasn't my favourite in the earlier series ( I prefered the Saber model before it). If you tuned the sail for top end it felt a bit gutless and when bagged out for light wind it quickly became back handed - hence I refrered to it as the Hellpussy.

However I did have an opportunity to play with a 2012 model Hellcat, but no real wind to test properly. What i did notice is that even when DH to max reccommended it still had heaps of curve / belly under the boom, while the top was twisting nicely. So if you're looking at Hellcat I'd go for the 2012, very nice!.

But definitely try your mast on the prospect sail before buying or use the reccommended mast.

Most of the current brands are very good sails but can feel very different on the water, so it also comes down a little to what sort of feel you're used to.

Hey Des,

The 2013 Hellcat goes one step further on than the 2012 version. Had a great sail on the new 6.7 up in QLD a couple of week back and was amazed at the top end range it had. No draft movement at all in up to 25 knots along with the rotation you expect out of a no cam rig make it a sweet set up for blasting and GPS.

It'll out perform many race sail setups for sure.

But then again had some nice sessions on the 2012 NCX early last Summer and that was a super nice setup also.

Seems you have some good choices these days so demo if you can.

Sam.



flatout
85 posts
5 Jul 2012 10:08PM
Thumbs Up

I think batten numbers plays a huge role in the no-cam freeride sails. If you are not looking for speed, but manouverability a 4-5 batten setup will feel lighter, whereas if you want speed more battens wil give you more stability but also a heavier feel.

I just got a simmer zero-five, 5 battens, very small windrange and gets overpowered really easy, but feels very light. I love it, but i'm not going for speed.
I've tried a bunch of different freerace no-cams, inc ncx. My favourite is without a doubt the gaastra savage.

Jezstrt
TAS, 1471 posts
6 Jul 2012 12:49PM
Thumbs Up

WINDSURFnSNOW said...


so demo if you can.

Sam.


Best advice so far

sboardcrazy
NSW, 8292 posts
6 Jul 2012 2:07PM
Thumbs Up

I just bought a 2nd hand 2008 NX sailworks 7.2m. It is cammed but I was comparing its weight to that of a non cammed freeride 7.3 (ok its a little bigger but...) website spec).They were both 5.2kgs or pretty close.
The cams on the NX rotate really well.It is heavy to uphaul but it doesn't seem to hold that much water.

timford
NSW, 510 posts
6 Jul 2012 5:04PM
Thumbs Up

Hellcat



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Windsurfing General


"Best no cam free ride sail" started by Mistral Nick