Please note: We are temporarily in maintenance mode, and some features, such as Buy&Sell, Forums and Messaging are temporarily offline. Back soon!

Forums > Stand Up Paddle   Board Talk & Reviews

psh hull aa or naish mana.

Reply
Created by calbs > 9 months ago, 15 Oct 2011
calbs
SA, 86 posts
16 Oct 2011 1:14AM
Thumbs Up

Looking for best option want a allrounder board which is going to last the distance in build quaulity and performance in small waves 1 to 4 ft and flat water paddling with kids aboard (3 kids ages 2yrs to 8yrs) .ive demoed a 2010 mana 10' was happy with it but didnt get to try in waves.Im also going to demo psh hull aa 10'2 & 10,10 .the psh boards are cheaper but dont want to buy & find out build quality is cheap.
Before i saw the psh hull i was set on mana ast 2012 model but unsure now any feed back would be appreciated.
when wind is up i kitesurf but am keen to get into suping for the windless days any excuse to get on the water.(my weight is 80 to 85 kgs)
cheers

TheGoodDr
SA, 216 posts
17 Oct 2011 12:36AM
Thumbs Up

Can't comment on other boards but the Mana is super stable in the surf and very manageable in that size range. You'd probably fit all three kids on at once. Build quality is good but they do chip when hit with paddle,as with most sups.

Good luck.

DavidJohn
VIC, 17569 posts
17 Oct 2011 8:04AM
Thumbs Up

This is my friend taking her kid for a paddle on my old 10' Mana.. It's fine for small kids but it would be a struggle with bigger kids on board.. The 10'5" Mana would be better if you want to paddle with the bigger kids on board.

DJ

Leroy13
VIC, 1174 posts
17 Oct 2011 10:57AM
Thumbs Up

The quality of the Hull paddlers is good but they are very easily chipped. get rail tape. They are also quite heavy. They paddle really well, are super stable and whatever they are made of (Ferro Cement?) seems indestructible. At your weight the 10'10" seems a great option for all the things you want to do.

calbs
SA, 86 posts
17 Oct 2011 3:49PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks heaps guys for the feed back .going to take psh for demo real soon then make up mind cheers

calbs
SA, 86 posts
17 Oct 2011 3:53PM
Thumbs Up

also crew just wondering do all sups have the vent valve on them .just wondering if they can fail and let in water.i now the psh does ,anyone now if mana does.

DavidJohn
VIC, 17569 posts
17 Oct 2011 8:05PM
Thumbs Up

calbs said...

also crew just wondering do all sups have the vent valve on them .just wondering if they can fail and let in water.i now the psh does ,anyone now if mana does.


Not all boards have a vent screw.. My Mana does.. and yes they can fail and let water in but the ones that fail are usually the gor-tex maintenance free type.

btw.. my bamboo deck 2011 Mana has one of those (gortex plugs) and its been fine.. (touch wood).

DJ

calbs
SA, 86 posts
17 Oct 2011 9:45PM
Thumbs Up

cheers DJ.

AA
NSW, 2167 posts
18 Oct 2011 12:04PM
Thumbs Up

calbs said...

also crew just wondering do all sups have the vent valve on them .just wondering if they can fail and let in water.i now the psh does ,anyone now if mana does.


Calbs in the last 12 months we have not had a Goretex vent screw fail on either a Naish or a PSH board. Gore vents are set-and-forget and an industry standard.

AA
NSW, 2167 posts
18 Oct 2011 12:09PM
Thumbs Up

Leroy13 said...

The quality of the Hull paddlers is good but they are very easily chipped. get rail tape. They are also quite heavy. They paddle really well, are super stable and whatever they are made of (Ferro Cement?) seems indestructible. At your weight the 10'10" seems a great option for all the things you want to do.


Yep the Hull AA paddlers are bomb proof. We don't like boards breaking.
As always it is trade off and to get the boards down to the $1000 mark, this is the best construction.

WINDSURFnSNOW
NSW, 1613 posts
Site Sponsor
18 Oct 2011 7:48PM
Thumbs Up

AA said...

calbs said...

also crew just wondering do all sups have the vent valve on them .just wondering if they can fail and let in water.i now the psh does ,anyone now if mana does.


Calbs in the last 12 months we have not had a Goretex vent screw fail on either a Naish or a PSH board. Gore vents are set-and-forget and an industry standard.


Which Naish boards have a Goretex valve?

JonWest
QLD, 105 posts
18 Oct 2011 7:31PM
Thumbs Up

AA said...

calbs said...

also crew just wondering do all sups have the vent valve on them .just wondering if they can fail and let in water.i now the psh does ,anyone now if mana does.


Calbs in the last 12 months we have not had a Goretex vent screw fail on either a Naish or a PSH board. Gore vents are set-and-forget and an industry standard.


Set and forget? Don't think so. Failure to wash out with fresh water will see the gortex material clog with salt crystals rendering the vent useless.
Boards with vents are a good indication the foam core is of a less density and strength quality. Less dense foam has more air bubbles which means more air to expand and contract in varying temperatures. Failure to have a vent in these situations will see your board quickly delaminate

AA
NSW, 2167 posts
18 Oct 2011 11:38PM
Thumbs Up

Jon we have not seen any such issues here. My gore valve still bubbles away merrily after 18 months. I never touch it.
Sam, some of last years Bamboo veneer boards had Gore valves.

Leroy13
VIC, 1174 posts
18 Oct 2011 11:39PM
Thumbs Up

Depends on construction, AA is right and JonWest is wrong although I give the vent an empty out every fourth or fifth surf.
Hey people get so damn technical. Its Bull---t. Have fun and choose what suits you best I've had the PSH paddler for around 6 months and this is a non issue.

Leroy13
VIC, 1174 posts
18 Oct 2011 11:40PM
Thumbs Up

Jinx AA

calbs
SA, 86 posts
28 Oct 2011 11:50PM
Thumbs Up

finaly made a purchase on a board went with the mana 10'.
I got lucky found a sup school which was selling some older board got the bamboo 2010 .as soon as i jumbed on it i new it was the board for me & what i wanted top quality boards .As this is my first sup i decided tio go second hand then down the track this can be handed to kids & wife & ill buy a smaller mana 9'5 or n9'.
Im stoked with my purchase . Big thanks for all your advice about board choice .cant wait for some swell to come our way to try in surf.
cheers calbs.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle   Board Talk & Reviews


"psh hull aa or naish mana." started by calbs