Please note: We are temporarily in maintenance mode, and some features, such as Buy&Sell, Forums and Messaging are temporarily offline. Back soon!

Forums > Stand Up Paddle   Board Talk & Reviews

give me a vote, help me choose...

Reply
Created by JohnnySUP > 9 months ago, 23 Jul 2012
JohnnySUP
17 posts
23 Jul 2012 11:22PM
Thumbs Up

I'm 45 years old, 80kg and want to surf smallish (2-6ft) waves all next winter on the north shore of the Dominican Republic. My level is intermediate, i windsurf lots, kite surf in light wind with 6ft surfboard strapless and longboard a little. I'm recovering from whiplash and cant really surf at all anymore. I've been out in overhead surf with a 10.6 and a 9.6 SUP and caught many waves, both times i had starboards that felt big. I've made up a list below, if you could just give a top three, that would help me choose. Ive stuck to about 130L and about 9'. My goal is to find a board to catch lots of waves and be able to progress surfing (without suffering too much). The waves in DR are not fast and the periods vary from 7-10. There is often chop. You dont have to paddle too far out the get to the break. At one point i will for sure get a longer cruiser that i can downwind with and surf breaks along the way. Anyway, thanks for your time!

1 - Coreban - Fusion 9'0¨- 29.5 x 4.5 x 9.0 - 148L - ?lbs
2 - Starboard - Converse 9'0¨- 30 x 4.1 x 9.0 - 137L - 9.7kg
3 - Starboard - Pocket Rocket 8'5¨- 30 x 4.1 x 8.5 - 130L - 9.5kg
4 - PSHawaii - 9' 2" All Arounder (boardworks) - 28.5 x 4.5 x 9.2 - 154L - ?lb
5 - PSHawaii - 9' 2" WIDE Ripper - 29 5/8 x 4 1/4 x 9.3 - 126L - ?lb
6 - PSHawaii - 8' 9" WIDE Ripper - 29 3/4 x 4 1/4 x 8.9 - 120L - ?lb
7 - Naish Mana - 9'0¨- 29 5/8 x4 x 9.0 - 140L - 19lbs
8 - Jimmy Lewis Kwad - 9'1¨- 30 x 4 1/8 x 9.1 - 130L - ?lbs
9 - Jimmy Lewis Striker - 8'11"¨- 31 x 4 x 8.11 - 130L - ?lbs
10- C4 Waterman Forward-Vee Vector - 9'4¨- 29 x 4 x 9.4 - 137L - 19lbs
11- C4 Waterman SubNine Waterskate - 9'0¨- 29 x 4.25 x 9.0 - 134L - 22lbs
12- Fanatic Allwave - 8'10¨- 31 x ? x 8.10 - 146L - ?lbs
13- Fanatic Allwave - 9'2¨- 31.5 x ? x 9.2 - 160L - ?lbs
14- Naish Hokua - 9'5¨- 29.5 x 4 3/8 x 9.5 - 140L - 19lbs

DavidJohn
VIC, 17569 posts
24 Jul 2012 10:41AM
Thumbs Up

Welcome to The Breeze.. All those are great boards.. I don't know them all well but I do know the Naish boards and if you like to nose ride and that long board feel the Mana is a great board.. If you like that short board feel the Hokua is also a great board and probably my pick of the bunch.. The PSH boards are more performance suring boards.. Also great.. There's a new Starboard 9'1" that I've heard some good raves about.. Try and demo if you can.. If you are still recovering from an injury maybe you should concider something a little bigger with more stability but still with great performance.. Like my new 10'6".5 Nalu.. It's very different to the old Naish 10'6".. You can also put a windsurfing rig on it.

DJ

Jeroensurf
1100 posts
24 Jul 2012 6:04PM
Thumbs Up

If you SUP in slow and choppy waves I would considder a bit wider board.
I Paddle at the Northsea in Holland except that we don,t have turtles, palmtrees, +30-35C and blue/green water we share the same slow waves and chop on them.

On the occasional very above average days I love my Hokua9.0 but on most days the board isnt generating enough speed on the waves to get the best of it and I fall of a lot due the chop.
Most of those days I grab the Mana9.5 from the rentalstation if I wanna noseride or my Starboard WP8.10.
With a Quadsetup that board is still very stable in the chop, catches the wave pretty early and keeps speed in slower waves while turning on a dime.
In big fast hollow waves the board starts to bounche and is to fat, but on the slower chaotic stuff I like it a lot.
I,m 10kg heavier so youi might get away with one size smaller like the PR, but my 2 cents: think wide if the chop and slow waves are predominantly!

KimXS
WA, 7 posts
24 Jul 2012 6:17PM
Thumbs Up

No. 8 & No. 9 would be my choice....both boards rip.

Jradedmondo
NSW, 637 posts
24 Jul 2012 8:20PM
Thumbs Up

nice selection of boards there, cant really comment on any of those as i've mainly surfed customs, i have heard good things about the allwaves, i did demo some of the widepoint boards the other day, had a crack on the 8'2 spot on 130l, had a little paddle did alot of falling but then again im 115kg, really you just have to demo as many as you can and see what you like

Jarryd

Gassa
QLD, 272 posts
24 Jul 2012 8:38PM
Thumbs Up

fanatic allwave 9' 2

JohnnySUP
17 posts
24 Jul 2012 8:40PM
Thumbs Up

well, thanks for the answers. I forgot to mention that I live in a landlocked country (switz) and dont have access to any of the 'surf' types sups. Lots of larger sups on the lakes... its almost impossible to buy sups in the DR so will have to bring one, will stop on my way through in Miami and should be able to find all big brands I think. That also limits me to under 10ft luggage limitations, and no time to demo anything, bit risky. So what would be the safe bet, but still surfable in a smallish wave environment, where a good day is quantity and not necessarily quality.

The fanatic 9'2 has so much vol, and it very wide, the winter waves can sometimes get pretty perfect and i'm worried about performance. I like the naish mana 9'0, but am affraid i will get my old nickname back 'McSplash'. Is it stable? I'm 6ft 80kg and kind of sporty the c4 9' waterskate looks dope, anyone riding this board?

thanks again, j

n8wx
NSW, 253 posts
24 Jul 2012 11:31PM
Thumbs Up

I'd say...

Naish Hokua - 9'5¨

or

PSHawaii - 9' 2" WIDE Ripper

micksmith
VIC, 1701 posts
25 Jul 2012 8:40AM
Thumbs Up

taking into consideration all that you have mentioned, I would recommend a custom, but because you have asked for recommendations on these boards it would be down to three boards.
PSH 9'2"
naish 9'5"
PSH 8'9"
in that order.

GizzieNZ
4103 posts
25 Jul 2012 4:02PM
Thumbs Up

I would be contrary & say the starboard 8'5 pro

Leroy13
VIC, 1174 posts
27 Jul 2012 12:13AM
Thumbs Up

JohnnySUP said...

well, thanks for the answers. I forgot to mention that I live in a landlocked country (switz) and dont have access to any of the 'surf' types sups. Lots of larger sups on the lakes... its almost impossible to buy sups in the DR so will have to bring one, will stop on my way through in Miami and should be able to find all big brands I think. That also limits me to under 10ft luggage limitations, and no time to demo anything, bit risky. So what would be the safe bet, but still surfable in a smallish wave environment, where a good day is quantity and not necessarily quality.

The fanatic 9'2 has so much vol, and it very wide, the winter waves can sometimes get pretty perfect and i'm worried about performance. I like the naish mana 9'0, but am affraid i will get my old nickname back 'McSplash'. Is it stable? I'm 6ft 80kg and kind of sporty the c4 9' waterskate looks dope, anyone riding this board?

thanks again, j


Sorry I have to ask, where do you get perfect waves in Switzerland?

Cuttlefish
QLD, 1332 posts
27 Jul 2012 5:54PM
Thumbs Up

Goes home to Switzerland for the yodelling, chocolate and milk maids with a stop over at the favoured banking institution to pick up cash for sup'ing on the North Shore of the Dominican republic.

JohnnySUP
17 posts
27 Jul 2012 7:00PM
Thumbs Up

@ leroy, dont appologize just read the first sentence.
@ scuttlefish, you forgot the all important coocoo clocks and the fact that i ski to school and speak swedish.

Cuttlefish
QLD, 1332 posts
27 Jul 2012 9:59PM
Thumbs Up

Yog taala Svenska mucket dawligt.
BUT
Yog elska Svenska flickven.
Excuse my miss-spelt phonetics (gettin old and my memory is failing me).



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle   Board Talk & Reviews


"give me a vote, help me choose..." started by JohnnySUP