Forums > Stand Up Paddle   Board Talk & Reviews

Kialoa Hulu vs v drive

Reply
Created by Foam > 9 months ago, 7 Apr 2018
Foam
WA, 768 posts
7 Apr 2018 10:28AM
Thumbs Up

one better than other or similar for all water, Hulu does look thin any damage regards to this or rather having to cotton wool the hulu

Foam
WA, 768 posts
7 Apr 2018 10:30AM
Thumbs Up

I'm needed two new paddles, I'm tempted to get one of these in adjustable shaft , but seems pointless to do so in such a high end paddle , but I read somewhere a few racers and down winders use the adjustable as it can be well... adjusted on the fly if conditions change

JEG
VIC, 1469 posts
7 Apr 2018 1:19PM
Thumbs Up

both nice paddle and will do a great job.
sup paddle is a preference thing to which brand.
if you can, best to buy two paddle, fix and adjustable.

Area10
1508 posts
8 Apr 2018 12:44PM
Thumbs Up

I have both paddles. Both are great. But I use the v-drive exclusively now. It is hugely popular on the international racing circuit, and I can see why. I use v-drives for surfing, downwinding, and racing. Basically, everything except shallow rocky rivers etc where I use a plastic-bladed paddle.

Don't worry about the Hulu being a thin blade though - it's very tough nevertheless. The Kialoa paddles are plenty durable, as are the paddles from the other paddle-specific brands such as KeNalu and ZRE etc: If all you make is paddles, you wouldn't be in business very long if you made ones that break easily.

Foam
WA, 768 posts
9 Apr 2018 9:30AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Area10 said..
I have both paddles. Both are great. But I use the v-drive exclusively now. It is hugely popular on the international racing circuit, and I can see why. I use v-drives for surfing, downwinding, and racing. Basically, everything except shallow rocky rivers etc where I use a plastic-bladed paddle.

Don't worry about the Hulu being a thin blade though - it's very tough nevertheless. The Kialoa paddles are plenty durable, as are the paddles from the other paddle-specific brands such as KeNalu and ZRE etc: If all you make is paddles, you wouldn't be in business very long if you made ones that break easily.


Thanks, I see the v drive has different sizes also and a hybrid construction vs full carbon, as with my kialoa I guess full carbon is preferred in the v drive

Area10
1508 posts
9 Apr 2018 1:59PM
Thumbs Up

Well, it just depends how much money you want to spend. The full carbon v-drives (especially with the truly excellent oval tapered shaft) is pretty expensive. And although obviously most of the elite paddlers would use the most expensive versions, I've seen some of the world's top racers occasionally using the cheaper vector net versions.

You can use the Quickblade chart to decide what size blade to use. If in doubt between two sizes, go the smaller of the two sizes you are considering.

You would probably go a blade size smaller in the v drive than a kialoa since the v drive "catch" is very solid.

Foam
WA, 768 posts
9 Apr 2018 3:57PM
Thumbs Up

Thanks, I decided on the Hulu small, purely based on its full carbon and a very good price offer

Foam
WA, 768 posts
10 Apr 2018 11:21AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Area10 said..
Well, it just depends how much money you want to spend. The full carbon v-drives (especially with the truly excellent oval tapered shaft) is pretty expensive. And although obviously most of the elite paddlers would use the most expensive versions, I've seen some of the world's top racers occasionally using the cheaper vector net versions.

You can use the Quickblade chart to decide what size blade to use. If in doubt between two sizes, go the smaller of the two sizes you are considering.

You would probably go a blade size smaller in the v drive than a kialoa since the v drive "catch" is very solid.


Do you go 7 or 8 above ? I'm confortable with either but 8 might be better

Foam
WA, 768 posts
10 Apr 2018 5:40PM
Thumbs Up

That qb chart is wrong or not consistent I went to check both paddles

one at 163 and one at 173 it's a inch difference on the same calculation

JEG
VIC, 1469 posts
10 Apr 2018 8:00PM
Thumbs Up

Is just a guide, start with long shaft then cut it down as required.

Foam
WA, 768 posts
10 Apr 2018 6:14PM
Thumbs Up

So keep it at 8 which does seem to be the most popular

Foam
WA, 768 posts
11 Apr 2018 2:35PM
Thumbs Up

Any others at 8 or ... just finalising

Area10
1508 posts
11 Apr 2018 7:16PM
Thumbs Up

Well, try it at 8 and if it's too short then cut another inch off it! If you hot glue and tape the handle on rather than use epoxy glue then you can change lengths at will.

No-one can tell you *exactly* what length is right for you. You'll have to experiment and find out for yourself. Each body is different, each board is a different thickness, and each paddling style is different. So keep your options open until you've got a bit more experience.

Foam
WA, 768 posts
13 Apr 2018 4:47AM
Thumbs Up

Yep, understand that, but from what your saying 8 is a bit long regardless if it's the starting point

Area10
1508 posts
14 Apr 2018 6:28AM
Thumbs Up

Select to expand quote
Foam said..
Yep, understand that, but from what your saying 8 is a bit long regardless if it's the starting point



Ok well if you are determined to risk cutting it too short for you, then by all means go ahead.

Otherwise, do what everyone else does and eg. start at 9" overhead, try it, and then if it's too long cut it down an inch, try it again, and if it's too long cut another inch off etc and keep going until it feels right.

Many people have their paddle 8" overhead (or longer). A friend of mine cut his kialoa at 9" overhead regrets not having it longer.

But some people have paddles that are their height or even smaller.

I'll say it one more time only: no-one can tell you exactly what is right for you. You just have to experiment for yourself. The Quickblade charts are a useful guide but that's all. It's your responsibility to choose the right length for you.

Why not borrow an adjustable paddle and find out what is right for you?

Foam
WA, 768 posts
14 Apr 2018 6:32AM
Thumbs Up

Thanks but I'm only referring to 14 ft boards, I have my surf paddles at head high but never had a 14 before

Foam
WA, 768 posts
14 Apr 2018 6:34AM
Thumbs Up

So basicly , to not make a screw up 8 is the safest bet I guess as you mention this is where most on 14 ft boards are sitting at.

Area10
1508 posts
14 Apr 2018 7:28AM
Thumbs Up

There is no safe bet. Only guesses, unless you try it out for yourself.

8" might not be right for you.
7" might not be right for you.
9" might not be right for you.

I now have my paddle at 6", that I use with my 14ft boards.

i used to use one that was 13"
overhead.

My friend uses one that's about 10" overhead on his 14s.

But another friend uses his surf paddle on his 14, which is around head high.

So stop guessing and start trying. There is no sure solution.

Or else stop asking and make a guess. If it's too short then you can always sell your paddle and start again, or cut it down to use as a surf paddle.

You can't make a complex situation simpler than it can ever be.



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Stand Up Paddle   Board Talk & Reviews


"Kialoa Hulu vs v drive" started by Foam