Select to expand quote
2bish said..Galatea said..
Both cloths are nice. The 9.52oz is more than adequate weight wise.
i really like the Cdx, it is our preferred option in cruise laminates.
The shape retention life of the cdx would be better, plus a more complicated cut hence the difference in price.
But the physical life of the polypreg Dacron would be longer, if that makes sense?
Sailmaker of 40+ years.
Good luck and happy sailing, there is nothing like a new sail.
Hi Galatea, thanks for that and great to have your input as a sailmaker. My current main is Dacron and probably the original one on the boat, so that's going on 20 years now. I get that the Dacrons just keep on going and last longer overall and the new Dacrons are better, but I also realize that they're pretty bagged out for a large proportion of that life. At 20 years, mine is pretty hard to control when the wind gets up in speed, so I've learnt to reef early, really early

So with average use, would you say I'm going to keep good shape for at least 5 years with the CDX? And then shape holding will taper off over the next 5 years and I'd be looking at replacement in say 10 years or less?
Also what's your take on CDX and reefing? I've seen some comments elsewhere that it deteriorates more quickly with reefing, however they seemed to be older comments on S.A. so maybe that was an issue with the earlier versions of the laminate?
I'm toying with the idea of getting a third reef put in, like a storm tri proportion. Do you ever do that and what do you think? Is it just adding extra weight up high for something I may hardly use, if ever?
Yep I can't wait to have a crisp new sail, I do like to fiddle with controls and this old one has been frustrating from that point of view.
I think that is a reasonable expectancy of cdx lifespan. But hours usage is the key, that is why charter companies use Dacron. Cdx will last a long time when used sparingly but your time frame estimate is reasonable for weekend use and the odd cruise in Tasmanian waters ( I would not use any laminate in tropics!).
The New CDX pro which I assume is the cloth specified is better for reefing as it has a soft hand, a quality often overlooked in cruising cloth in these days of racing technology adapted for the cruising market.
But resilience to folding and flex is the reason Dacron has longevity compared to laminate, I often use the analogy of a handkerchief and a plastic sheet, stretch the woven handkerchief across the bias (opposite corners) and it will stretch, let it go and it springs back. Do the same with plastic, much harder to stretch but will not spring back, it will take the deformed shape.
Not as pronounced obviously but still a factor over time.
lydia points re reefing are very valid.
The third reef absolutely, even if it is a higher second reef in a third reef position, this is actually a good idea if your boom has two reefing lines ( as most do). You have a reef to balance the overpowering and then straight into a survival reef without having to re reeve a reefing line. Tri sails are fine if you see the weather coming!
The most important thing to a cruising boat is to be able to beat off a Lee shore in adverse conditions without a motor.
Anything else wrong you just get hungry! ??