Please note: We are temporarily in maintenance mode, and some features, such as Buy&Sell, Forums and Messaging are temporarily offline. Back soon!

Forums > Kitesurfing Gear Reviews

Hook Knife - One Piece Stainless Steel

Reply
Created by Surfer62 > 9 months ago, 26 Jun 2007
Surfer62
1357 posts
26 Jun 2007 8:34PM
Thumbs Up


Check out this hook knife, stronger and more usable
than the dakine, and no seperate parts or screwed bits like the dakine.

Gerber brand, a bit more exy, but I've ordered one cause they look like they will last forever.

http://cgi.ebay.com.au/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewItem&item=270137817762&ssPageName=ADME:B:EF:US:11

cheers

kite boy
WA, 354 posts
27 Jun 2007 6:41PM
Thumbs Up

looks safe NOT dumb f$£%

windpig
QLD, 113 posts
27 Jun 2007 9:05PM
Thumbs Up

you must be joking! that hook knife would take your finger off .
real kite knives will only let lines come in contact with the blade,
hence the narrow slot,which also hold the line captive so if lines are under tension can be a one handed operation.they don't cut that easy.

RayQ
WA, 636 posts
27 Jun 2007 8:00PM
Thumbs Up

Looks serious, I think the hook is too big, there may be issues while trying to get it out of the pocket or where ever your store it, it could catch, might as well just get a knife blade that wont jam up. I thought SOS have got a hook knife for a lot less $

Ray

sbray
SA, 350 posts
28 Jun 2007 5:11PM
Thumbs Up

Hi guys,

I am new to kiting and am looking at various sites in Oz.

I stumbled across two distributors for the hook cutters but I'm not sure as to how they would last in salt conditions.

The good news is that the smaller type are only $8.00.

http://www.ferno.com.au/products/productList.cfm?
catID=2&subCat=218&selCat=218

www.firerescue.com.au/firebusters/search/details.php?id=33

joespencer
QLD, 167 posts
28 Jun 2007 9:48PM
Thumbs Up

this one has a built in ceramic sharpener for the replaceable blades, and a screwdriver...

www.knifecenter.com/kc_new/store_detail.html?s=ONASEK2

or this one is nice and small with a hard plastic sheath

www.knifecenter.com/kc_new/store_detail.html?s=BM5BLK

Surfer62
1357 posts
28 Jun 2007 8:37PM
Thumbs Up

The gerber is actually only about 10mm longer than the dakine which has a slippery odd shaped handle. The hook area is the same size as the dakine. The gerber has a hole for your forefinger and the rest of the handle is in your palm and yes I have compared both at the same time.

Anything cheap is unlikely to stand up to the marine environment and may never be used, until.......... its actually needed!! Steer away from anything that has interchangable parts obviously not made to last.

Look at all the options and make your own decision. Thanks to the other guys that have researched them as well.

BoDiddly
VIC, 622 posts
29 Jun 2007 11:48AM
Thumbs Up

Do we know which ones of these are stainless? a rusty blade is not really going to help me if I need it!

joespencer
QLD, 167 posts
29 Jun 2007 8:26PM
Thumbs Up

generally the better ones are stainless, and say so- however there is little that stainless can do against constant salt water- the razor cutting edge corrodes leaving a dull blade-which is too dull to cut lines. "Benchmade" have a salt water steel (H1) - but they don't make a line cutter in it, only dive knives/rescue folders.
i have found that you have to resharpen periodically, and wash in fresh water after coming in, you can prevent the blade dulling with time. I think replaceable blades are good as long as they can be resharpened. (o/w replacing blades all the time)

also, the better quality the stainless the better the edge retention in salt water. gerber is ok, benchmade is better.

Neill
VIC, 484 posts
5 Jul 2007 12:55AM
Thumbs Up

Anyone thought of using a pair of very good quality small garden shears? I would think that a pair of good shears would make mincemeat out of a kite line, it would take just one snip of a tensioned line to release it.

Perhaps a pair of good quality stainless craft scissors would do the job as well?

Christina
WA, 29 posts
11 Jul 2007 3:46PM
Thumbs Up

The hook knives you guys use kiting look all tiny and useless compared to the ones i use when i hang glide. We use the Jack Safety knife

www.moyes.com.au/file-not-found

Which is about 25cm long and retails for about $30. Mine hasnt corroded yet, but i've never been unfortunate enough to have to use it. Although i guess it's a bit too big to tote around on your harnesses.. No specialised pockets or such.. Although I think they make a smaller version.

The ever stupid paragliders (i love them dearly, but why would ya do it?) have made up a whole page dedicated to hook knives, so if you want a bit of a read about them, head to:

www.paragliding-tales-and-reviews.com/paraglider-hook-knife.html

One last thing. Dont use your hook knife to cut bits of rope nad stuff, it's there to save your life and you want it to be as sharp as possible when you're in trouble. If you think it's getting a bit blunt, is $10-$30 too much to spend to replace a piece of equipment that could save your life?



Subscribe
Reply

Forums > Kitesurfing Gear Reviews


"Hook Knife - One Piece Stainless Steel" started by Surfer62